(de-news.net) – Armin Willingmann, the lead candidate for the Saxony-Anhalt SPD, is in favor of incorporating the majority of mini-jobs into Germany’s social insurance system, but he contends that university students should continue to be exempt due to their financial situation and cautions that doing away with student mini-jobs could promote informal employment. His stance is in line with the larger political discussion around the Pension Commission’s proposals.
Willingmann argued that mini-jobs should be permanently retained for university students while expressing broad support for the Pension Commission’s proposal to convert most of these positions into regular employment subject to mandatory social insurance contributions. Although he endorsed the commission’s broader objective of strengthening the pension system, he maintained that students represent a distinct group whose employment circumstances justify a lasting exemption from the planned changes.
Willingmann said mini-jobs had served as an appropriate labor-market instrument during periods of substantially higher unemployment, when they provided employers with flexibility and created opportunities for labor market participation. However, he argued that current economic conditions, marked by persistent shortages of skilled workers across many sectors, now support shifting the majority of mini-jobs into standard employment relationships that include full social insurance coverage. At the same time, he acknowledged that industries such as retail, hospitality, and other service sectors remain heavily dependent on flexible staffing arrangements and would therefore require transitional measures to adapt to the proposed reforms.
Even so, Willingmann contended that university students should continue to be exempt from the new rules. He argued that individuals engaged in long-term employment should generally contribute to the social insurance system and accumulate pension entitlements throughout their working lives. Students, by contrast, are only at the beginning of their careers and typically work to finance their education rather than establish long-term employment histories. For that reason, he said, allowing them to retain a larger share of their earnings during their studies is more important than requiring pension contributions at this stage, since they will have decades to build retirement entitlements after entering full-time employment.
Merz and Söder signal further talks
Willingmann also cautioned that eliminating student mini-jobs could unintentionally encourage undeclared or informal employment. He argued that such a risk has become more significant because the long-anticipated increase in student financial assistance under the planned ‘BAföG’ student allocation reform has been postponed until next year, leaving many students with continued financial pressures while studying.
The Pension Commission has recommended integrating most mini-jobs into the regular social insurance system as part of a broader effort to strengthen pension entitlement accumulation and expand the base of contributors financing Germany’s statutory pension system. At the same time, the commission proposed allowing exemptions for selected groups, including school students. The recommendations have prompted political debate, with business organizations warning that the changes could impose additional administrative and financial burdens on labor-intensive sectors such as retail and hospitality, while members of the governing coalition have adopted differing positions on how extensively the proposals should be implemented.
Although Willingmann broadly supports the commission’s overall direction, he has argued that university students should receive a permanent exemption from the reforms. His position mirrors one previously advocated by SPD Bundestag member Annika Klose and reflects a broader discussion within the party over how to balance pension sustainability with the financial circumstances of younger workers. Chancellor Friedrich Merz of the CDU and CSU leader Markus Söder have likewise indicated that additional negotiations will be necessary before any final decisions are reached, underscoring that the commission’s recommendations remain subject to further political consideration as coalition partners seek agreement on the future of the proposed reforms.
