(de-news.net) – As Berlin’s coalition talks revive plans to transfer around 160,000 homes into public ownership, Germany’s Federal Government faces mounting pressure to regulate the socialization of private housing. The Investment Protection Act proposed by Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU) would impose stricter expropriation requirements, including proof of necessity and compensation at full market value. While supporters argue that the legislation has a constitutional basis and property-sector representatives warn that prolonged uncertainty could deter investment, increase financing costs and worsen housing shortages, SPD politicians and legal scholars question whether the proposed restrictions would withstand constitutional review.
Germany’s Federal Government is facing growing pressure to introduce legislation restricting the socialization of privately owned housing, as the debate over Berlin’s plans exposes competing concerns about property rights, constitutional authority and the supply of affordable homes. The CDU Economic Council has called for the legislation to be adopted without delay. Wolfgang Steiger, the council’s secretary-general, backed Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt’s proposed Investment Protection Act, arguing that private property must remain protected from political interference because it forms the foundation of Germany’s economic system. Even if the planned restrictions ultimately withstand constitutional scrutiny, Steiger warned, prolonged uncertainty could damage the country’s reputation among domestic and international investors.
Dobrindt outlined the principal elements of the proposed legislation on Sunday. Under the plan, state governments seeking to socialize residential property would have to demonstrate a compelling necessity and establish that alternative measures, including new construction and housing subsidies, had been exhausted without achieving their objectives. Any expropriation would require prompt monetary compensation at full market value, determined through an independent appraisal. The proposal follows an agreement by the federal coalition of the SPD, the CDU and the CSU to establish nationwide rules governing the limits of state-level socialization legislation. However, the Government has so far presented only the main policy principles, rather than a formal bill. The timing and final legal provisions therefore remain unresolved.
Berlin’s housing plans face potential legal obstacles
The proposed federal restrictions could complicate efforts by Berlin’s Left Party, Greens and SPD to transfer approximately 160,000 apartments owned by large private real estate companies into public ownership. Under the three parties’ exploratory agreement, private companies holding at least 10,000 apartments in the capital would be subject to the proposed measure. The parties intend to introduce legislation by mid-2028 and have proposed limiting total compensation to 16 billion euros.
The Left Party argues that expanding municipal ownership could help contain rent increases across the wider housing market. Its representatives point to the moderating effect of publicly owned housing on rental prices as a reason to bring large private portfolios under public control. Eralp, the party’s leading candidate in Berlin, has said that five companies, including Vonovia, would be affected by the plan.
The initiative has become a central issue in the parties’ coalition negotiations, placing their housing policy in potential conflict with the Federal Government’s proposed investment protections. The dispute also raises broader questions about whether changing ownership structures can address affordability without discouraging investment in additional housing.
Vonovia and property-sector stakeholders warn of investment risks
Vonovia has argued that the proposed socialization would be unconstitutional and would not withstand judicial review. The company maintains that Germany’s housing shortage can be addressed only through substantial private investment supported by predictable regulation, legal certainty and a stable investment environment. Within its Berlin portfolio, the average rent is 8.26 euros per square meter. Vonovia has also reported that approximately 1,000 residential units are under construction. The company’s position reflects broader concerns within the real estate industry that uncertainty over property rights could undermine investor confidence and make it more difficult to finance new housing.
The debate extends beyond the companies directly affected by the Berlin proposal. Real estate developers, lenders and construction businesses also depend on a predictable legal framework when committing capital to projects that may take years to complete. Industry representatives argue that uncertainty surrounding ownership rights could influence investment decisions even before any legislation is enacted.
Former Justice Minister calls for faster legislation
Marco Buschmann, a Free Democratic Party (FDP) politician and former Federal Justice Minister, has also urged the Federal Government to submit the promised legislation promptly. He maintains that the Basic Law provides a constitutional basis for federal rules governing socialization and potentially permits restrictions on the transfer of housing into public ownership. In his assessment, a dedicated group of officials could prepare a legally sound proposal within a few months.
You may also like
Buschmann has separately questioned the constitutionality of Berlin’s plans, particularly the proposed compensation arrangements. He argues that compensation falling below half of a property’s market value would raise serious constitutional concerns. He has also challenged the criteria used to determine which housing companies would be affected, noting that the threshold has shifted during the political debate. In Buschmann’s view, the changing definition of a large housing company could raise questions under Article 3 of the Basic Law, which establishes the principle of equal treatment. The concern centers on whether companies in comparable circumstances could be treated differently according to a threshold that lacks a consistent justification.
Banks warn that financing could become more expensive
The Association of German Pfandbrief Banks (VDP), which represents approximately 50 real estate financiers, has warned that Berlin’s proposed socialization could deepen the housing shortage while increasing borrowing costs for households and property companies. Jens Tolckmitt, the association’s chief executive, argues that transferring existing apartments into public ownership would not create additional housing and could instead discourage the private investment needed to expand supply. He has also raised concerns about proposals associated with the Deutsche Wohnen & Co. Enteignen campaign to eliminate existing land charges without compensation, warning that such a change could undermine the collateral used in mortgage lending.
Land charges are an important component of property-backed financing. If lenders could no longer rely on established collateral arrangements, banks might reassess the risks associated with residential construction and home loans. Tolckmitt argues that the resulting uncertainty could make financing more expensive for both housing companies and private households seeking to purchase homes. He has called on the Federal Government to resolve the legal questions quickly, warning that a prolonged debate could weaken Germany’s reputation as a dependable destination for investment. The concern is not limited to the immediate financial consequences of socialization but also encompasses the credibility of the country’s legal and economic framework.
Atradius identifies additional risks for construction and real estate
Credit insurer Atradius has similarly identified the debate as an additional source of risk for Berlin’s property and construction industries. David Engelhardt, a manager in the company’s risk services division, argues that transferring existing housing into public ownership would alter the distribution of ownership without directly addressing the shortage of available homes.
Political uncertainty could also discourage developers and lenders at a time when construction activity is already constrained by high building costs, elevated interest rates, labor shortages, lengthy planning procedures and regulatory requirements. These pressures have made it more difficult for companies to bring projects to completion and secure the financing needed to expand residential supply.
For Atradius, the issue is therefore part of a wider assessment of the conditions affecting investment and credit risk in the construction sector. Uncertainty over property rights could compound existing financial pressures, particularly for businesses that rely on long-term projects and stable relationships with lenders, contractors and suppliers.
Housing completion figures underline the supply challenge
Germany’s housing statistics illustrate the difficulties facing the construction industry. Although 238,500 building permits were issued in 2025, only 206,600 homes were completed, the lowest annual completion figure since 2012. The number of completed homes is expected to decline further to approximately 185,000 this year, remaining substantially below the Federal Government’s longstanding target of 400,000 new homes annually.
The gap between permits and completed homes also reflects the time required to move projects through the construction process. Since 2020, the average period between approval and completion has increased by approximately seven months, reaching about 27 months. At the end of 2025, roughly 760,700 approved homes remained unfinished.
Atradius expects this backlog to persist as household numbers increase and new construction remains subdued. The figures highlight the distinction between approving housing projects and delivering homes that can actually be occupied. Even when projects have received permission, financial and administrative obstacles can delay completion.
The shortfall has been attributed to rising construction costs, expensive financing, shortages of skilled workers, extended planning procedures and complex administrative requirements. Atradius has emphasized the need for more predictable planning and investment conditions, alongside simpler construction processes, to make it easier to deliver housing at lower cost.
Construction insolvencies add to concerns about financial stability
Atradius is monitoring credit risks across the construction sector, including claims held by contractors, tradespeople and building-material suppliers against their customers. Demand for surety insurance and guarantees also remains high as businesses seek to protect liquidity and replace withheld security payments.
Engelhardt has reported an increase in losses associated with construction-sector insolvencies, suggesting that financial distress is affecting increasingly large companies. In this environment, uncertainty surrounding housing policy could have consequences beyond individual property owners and developers.
Delayed projects, payment defaults and further insolvencies could affect businesses throughout construction supply chains. Atradius therefore considers the reliability of the legal framework an important factor in maintaining confidence among investors, lenders and commercial partners. The company has also pointed to broader pressure on the construction industry, alongside difficulties in retail and manufacturing, as evidence of the need to improve the conditions for building.